An analysis of NSW proposed remake of the Biosecurity (National Livestock Identification System) Regulation 2017

NSW proposed remake of the Biosecurity (National Livestock Identification System) Regulation 2017

What the government proposed A remake of the NLIS Regulation with a mix of administrative updates and substantive changes. The main changes:

  • Full electronic identification (eID) for sheep and goats, with transitional provisions removed. From 1 January 2027, all sheep and goats must carry an eID device before leaving a property, whatever their age (some exclusions, such as harvested rangeland goats).
  • Removal of several identification exemptions, including movements between contiguous properties, short stays on neighbouring land, certain exhibitions and displays, some goat movements, and carcasses sent to specified facilities.
  • Public Property Identification Codes (PICs) in advertisements for the sale or disposal of identifiable livestock, including online ads.
  • New holding-yard movement, recordkeeping (two years) and NLIS reporting rules.
  • New two-year carcass movement records.
  • Standardised two-day (48-hour) reporting, and a two-day deadline to correct inaccurate NLIS information.
  • New offences with a $11,000 maximum and $1,000 penalty notices.
  • Some goat depot changes, including cutting the notice period for a new depot from 21 to 7 days.

The Department describes the costs as “marginal and largely transitional.”

Why the issue matters Livestock traceability supports rapid responses to animal disease, biosecurity emergencies, public health risks and chemical residue incidents, and it sustains confidence in livestock industries. Animal Care Australia supports these goals. The concern is that the burden will fall unevenly, hitting small-scale producers, hobby farmers, breeders, exhibitors and recreational owners hardest, since they cannot absorb compliance costs the way large enterprises can.

What Animal Care Australia identified

  • The Department’s “marginal” cost finding is an industry-wide average that hides much higher per-animal costs for small owners.
  • Removing exemptions, especially for short moves onto neighbouring land, is disproportionate to the actual risk.
  • Publishing PICs in ads may expose home addresses and make stock easier to locate, which raises privacy, theft and security concerns. Online ads can also stay searchable indefinitely.
  • “Holding yard” is not clearly defined, so ordinary on-property management could be caught.
  • Carcass recordkeeping is unfamiliar to occasional owners and needs templates and emergency-disposal guidance.
  • It is unclear whether “two days” means calendar or business days, and nothing protects people who miss deadlines through outages or other events outside their control.
  • The correction duty should run from when a person knew or reasonably ought to have known of the error.
  • Technology failures (NLIS or internet outages, scanner or software faults, power loss, disasters) are not recognised as excuses.
  • Penalties risk hitting honest administrative errors as hard as deliberate avoidance.
  • Education and guidance are not planned ahead of enforcement.
  • There is no formal post-implementation review.

Animal Care Australia’s recommendastions

  • A specific impact assessment for small and recreational owners, and a Small Operator Regulatory Impact Assessment covering the cumulative effect of eID, reporting, recordkeeping, advertising, equipment, training and penalties.
  • More financial support for eID, and no forced purchase of expensive equipment where cheaper options exist.
  • A risk assessment of each exemption proposed for removal. Retain low-risk exemptions, or use a simple notification or recordkeeping process instead.
  • A privacy, safety and security assessment before PICs are published. Consider giving the PIC to buyers, sales platforms or NLIS rather than the public.
  • A clear definition of “holding yard,” with worked examples.
  • Carcass record templates and emergency guidance.
  • Clarity on “two days” and reasonable-excuse protection.
  • Correction duties triggered by knowledge or reasonable awareness.
  • A reasonable-excuse or safe-harbour rule for verified technology failures, plus alternative reporting during outages.
  • Graduated enforcement: Education → Warning/Direction → Opportunity to rectify → Penalty, with penalties reserved for deliberate, repeated or high-risk conduct.
  • A comprehensive education campaign before enforcement starts.
  • A formal review 12–24 months after implementation, with industry and owner groups involved.

Outcome Animal Care Australia is seeking

Animal Care Australia wants the Regulation kept, with proportionality safeguards added: the traceability objectives are supported, but the burden on small and recreational owners should be assessed and reduced, not simply accepted. Specifically, a commitment to a post-implementation review.

Animal Care Australia’s submission

Leave a comment