An analysis of the Australian Animal Welfare Strategy (AAWS) final draft

What the government proposed

  • A national Australian Animal Welfare Strategy (AAWS) with a vision that Australia achieves good animal welfare through practices and standards underpinned by science and evidence.
  • A six-priority framework: Leadership and coordination; Standards and implementation; Reporting and compliance; Research and development; Education and communication; International engagement.
  • Chapters covering animals in the wild, research and teaching, work/sport/recreation, aquatic animals, companion animals, and livestock and production animals.
  • A framing of animal welfare as a shared responsibility across three tiers of government, industry, NGOs, vets and the community, built on existing arrangements. States and territories are not required to adopt it.

Why the issue matters

  • Animal welfare is governed by fragmented state and territory laws, so protections vary by jurisdiction, activity and species.
  • Without clear accountability, responsibility can be spread so widely that no one is answerable when welfare outcomes fail.
  • The Strategy only has practical value if it drives consistent, measurable improvements that states and territories will adopt. Animal Care Australia believes a vague non-mandatory strategy is unlikely to do that.

What Animal Care Australia identified

  • Governance: fragmented responsibilities, overlapping roles, no single independent state and territory authorities, weak accountability, and no clear ownership of outcomes.
  • Vision and measurement: no measurable outcomes, baselines, performance indicators, reporting timeframes or evaluation responsibility.
  • Compliance vs welfare: compliance systems are treated as a proxy for welfare, which Animal Care Australia believes technical compliance doesn’t guarantee good outcomes.
  • Enforcement: inconsistent penalties and powers, weak independent oversight, and too much reliance on NGOs (e.g. RSPCA inspectorates) for enforcement.
  • Wording: “trusted relationships” implies the current system works; “well defined” roles overstates clarity; the WOAH endorsement of the Five Domains is overstated; and the “exotic” label for companion animals is inappropriate.
  • Chapter gaps:
    • wildlife (welfare vs environmental management, humane lethal control),
    • research (expertise, lifetime welfare, replacement methods),
    • aquatic animals (gaps in legislation, the fishing sector), and
    • companion animals (online sales, shelter and rescue regulation, species-specific knowledge).

Animal Care Australia’s recommendations

  • Strengthen the Summary, Purpose and Vision so the AAWS is a national framework for driving, monitoring and evaluating continuous improvement, with defined responsibilities and measurable objectives.
  • Reword “Why Animals Matter” to ensure sentience is grounded in science, not turned into vague legal obligations. Reword the Five Domains line to “an internationally recognised, science-based framework”
  • Reframe the priorities:
    • Leadership: independent governance and oversight.
    • Standards: evidence-based minimums, practical and consistently applied, with regular review.
    • Reporting: measured welfare outcomes, not just compliance, with public transparency.
    • Research: balanced across all sectors, with a pathway to practical application.
    • Education: the top priority, proactive, accessible and species-specific, paired with compliance.
    • International: welfare as the aim, with trade as a by-product.
  • Regulate online sales and traceability, and the shelter and rescue sectors.
  • Set up independent Animal Welfare Commissions in each state and territory, establishing state-wide government-employed inspectorates for enforcement.
  • Treat animal welfare as its own objective, not one tied to productivity or trade.

Outcome Animal Care Australia is seeking

  • A stronger, more ambitious AAWS that moves beyond describing existing arrangements to driving real structural reform.
  • Independent, accountable governance: state and territory Animal Welfare Commissions providing coordination, expert advice, enforcement oversight and accountability.
  • Clear government obligations, measurable objectives, transparent reporting, funding, and evaluation of whether animal welfare is actually improving.
  • Success measured by demonstrable improvements in animal welfare, not by the commitments made.

Animal Care Australia’s submission

Leave a comment